HOTLINE (833) 667-6626 – WHAT DO I DO UNTIL HELP ARRIVES?
Imagine you are walking down Main Street in Nantucket and you see the Inky newspaper at the Hub and it's headline reads, "This week's Fish Flatulence Index high, expect possible island ferry delays". Say what!!!!? Some islanders might think, "Oh great, first it was nesting plovers, then seals and sharks, but now we have to worry about fish farts too?" Would you be curious enough to buy the paper? I bet you would want to at least read the article to make up your own mind about its credibility. Is it just fake news and a ploy to sell more newspapers? Read on before you conclude it is a joke.
First, let's learn a little about the fish we are talking about. Here is photo of the fish, taken in Nantucket harbor last year. These are menhaden, locally know as Bunker or Pogies. They are filter feeders, feeding off of phytoplankton when young and moving onto zooplankton when they mature. They never take a fish hook, so unless you snag or net one, you are out of luck fishing for them. If you look closely at the photo, you can see many of the fish swimming with mouths open and gill covers abducted, allowing water to flow across their gill rakers to catch food particles before swallowing. It has been estimated that one of these
fish can filter up to 4 gallons of sea water per minute, making them very efficient at clearing our bays, harbors and estuaries of algae. (By comparison, an oyster filters approximately 50 gallons of water per day).
So back to the newspaper headline from above. Acoustic biologists have shown that a similar schooling fish, herring, possibly communicate by passing gas in what is called high frequency repetitive ticks. It may be one way in which the fish alert one another to their presence in the school. If menhaden do this, how could that be enough to slow down the ferries you might ask? The feeling is if the fish can hear this, then predators of the fish possibly could also. Enter the humpback whale! How does a humpback find this tasty food item which it thrives on? Is it a serendipitous discovery or related to one of their senses? They don't echolocate like tooth whales so eliminate that sense. Their eyesight is limited, especially in water with poor visibility and their olfactory system is poorly developed for smell. That leaves their auditory system, which we know is well developed from listening to recordings of their songs. If this is the mechanism, then one would need to acoustically measure whether these fish sounds happen or not. That is exactly what the Gotham Whale stranding team, one of our partner stranding team members out of New York City is proposing to do. If funding is obtained, then acoustic biologists will head to New York harbor to listen for these fish sounds.
Some scientists feel that menhaden are the most valuable fish in the ocean. This is not for their palatability to humans because they are a very oily and bony fish, but because other animals thrive on their nutrient value. Birds such as osprey, northern gannets, terns, gulls cormorants, marine mammals such as whales, dolphins, porpoise, seals, other fish like striped bass, bluefish, tuna, flounder are just a few of the food chain members above them that benefit from their presence. Indirectly we have all probably eaten menhaden ground up in feed for chickens, beef and pigs or through omega 3 fatty acid supplements.
I would think you could consider menhaden a keystone species. Aside from their support of other species as a food source, they are also important for the environment. In Nantucket Harbor, high nitrogen and phosphorus levels from septic systems, lawn fertilizers, runoff, etc. contribute to algae blooms that cloud the water and prevent sunlight from reaching our endangered eel grass beds. These and other benthic plants then die, no longer produce oxygen, decompose and dead zones are created. Menhaden schools act like giant water filters in our harbors, removing algae blooms and transporting those nutrients out to sea when they leave or when they are eaten by other predatory animals.
Over fishing has severely depleted menhaden populations. Large factory ships using spotter planes locate large schools and encircle them with huge purse seine nets, decreasing their population and range. There needs to be more done to limit this devastation, as well as other activities that are depleting our oceans of fish.
I carried this a little further by creating the fictitious Fish Flatulence Index (FFI). The FFI is my made up term for a way to quantitate the presence of gassy fish, analogous to the Pollen Index we always refer to in summer for hay fever sufferers. In my scenario, a high FFI would theoretically indicate an abundance of menhaden and the greater likelihood of humpbacks in the area. Assuming that this theory is correct and the fish flatulence noise is attracting humpbacks, then indirectly the humpback attracting fish may present a hazard to shipping and necessitate ships to slowdown to avoid collision.
If you have been on island this fall, you are probably aware of the frequency that humpbacks are being seen close to the north shore, lunge feeding on bunker. Multiple times I have seen them just 30-50 yards off the beach or along the rip close to shore at Great Point. Videos have been posted on social media of them in and near the entrance to the harbor or by people on the ferries shortly before entering and leaving the harbor. MMAN has been vigilant whenever we have had reports of their proximity to the shipping lanes to notify the Coast Guard and the ferry terminals of the whales' presence. The last thing that we want is to have a collision, which can be fatal to the whale and hazardous to people on board.
Today the eastern seaboard is in the midst of 3 UMEs (unusual mortality events) concerning 3 large whales species (North Atlantic Right Whales, Minke and Humpbacks). From 2016 to the beginning of November 2020, a total of 136 humpbacks have been reported dead along the eastern seaboard from Maine to Florida. Many of the fatalities have been attributed to vessel strikes. We should do everything possible to prevent these vessel strikes, even if it means the future measuring of fish flatulence.
P.O. Box 3625
Nantucket, MA 02584
MMAN may contact you via SMS in order to request additional information regarding an injured animal or follow-up conversation if your cell phone is provided. MMAN will never share your personal information (name, address, e-mail, phone number) collected via website, form, social media or text with anyone. Information is collected for the sole purpose of communication regarding animals in need, volunteer opportunities or class registrations. To Opt-Out of text messages, text STOP.
©2025 Marine Mammal Alliance Nantucket
website by moor.studio
For all volunteer and education opportunities